| AMERICAN DIVISION | Liberty Division | Colonial Division | ||||
| 1st Team | 1st Team | 1st Team | Team | |||
| 106 | Carmine Sipper | Caldwell | Thomas Sica | CG | Oliver Kreizman | Columbia |
| 113 | Anthony Pellegrino | SHP | Jakob Ferrer | Bel | Jared Van Allen | Columbia |
| 120 | Nick Adams | West Orange | Sebastian Kristal | GR | Reid Ordower | Columbia |
| 126 | Solomon Soriente | Caldwell | Leo Tiankee | Bel | Milan Connolly | Columbia |
| 132 | Ethan Kerlin | West Essex | Connor Kerney | CG | Edwin Cuarezma | East Side |
| 138 | Thomas Ruane | West Essex | Gerard Immersi | CG | August Katz | Columbia |
| 144 | Reid Clausi | West Essex | Joel Gonzalez | Ver | Orlin Solarzano | East SIde |
| 150 | Nick Janish | West Essex | Jake Ferry | Ver | Michael Cetrulo | Newark Academy |
| 157 | Alex Diorio | Livingston | Finn Jones | Mont | Marcelo Gripi | East Side |
| 165 | Lorenzo Caamano | Caldwell | Aziah Robinson | Irv | Nyzairh Williams | NCA |
| 175 | Carmine Masi | West Essex | Robert Kelly | CG | Natan Da SIlva | East Side |
| 190 | Arthur Rosu | West Orange | Brett Molka | Mill | Jadon McCoy | Orange |
| 215 | Rocco Salerno | SHP | Jesse Gibbs | GR | Joderson Remys | Orange |
| 285 | Brandon Toranzo | Nutley | John Stockelberg | Ver | Emmanuel Okorie | East Side |
| At Large | Clark Rich | SHP | Rocco Negron | Bel | ||
| At Large | Alex Esposito | West Essex | Jake Saraiva | CG | ||
| At Large | Gabriel McCulloch | Bloomfield | Jon Jon Kurtsoy | Mill | Juan Osorto | East Side |
| At Large | Aidan Manning | SHP | Nicolas Costantini | CG | Menelik James | NCA |
| 2nd Team | Denis Roca | Orange | ||||
| 106 | Joey Viola | SHP | Gavin Nobles | Mont | Ryan Martins | East Side |
| 113 | Yankee Mabee | Caldwell | Narito Radomski | GR | Jackson Flores | Newark Academy |
| 120 | Dante D’Achille | West Essex | Lorenzo Tiankee | Bel | Timothy Howell Jr | NCA |
| 126 | Nick Bastante | West Essex | Jerry D’Alessio | CG | Kyler Harris | NCA |
| 132 | Rocco Conforti | Caldwell | Jesse Wagner | Ver | Christoly Georges | Orange |
| 138 | Marco Cocca | Caldwell | Aaron Amici | GR | Alexander Balsera | Newark Academy |
| 144 | Michael DeRosa | Caldwell | Alex Morales | Mill | Kwabena Abrokwa | East Side |
| 150 | Aidan Rotbaum | Nutley | Giovanni Cassilli | CG | Samuel Noel | Orange |
| 157 | Casey Farrell | SHP | Okwudili Onyeagoro | Irv | Sam Memo | Columbia |
| 165 | Joseph Jean-Marie | Livingston | Cristian Latorre | Ver | Niref Simpson | NCA |
| 175 | Nick Mignone | Caldwell | Gavin Gonch | Ver | Ibn Muhammad | EO |
| 190 | Andrew Fonseca | Caldwell | Billy Nicolas | Irv | ||
| 215 | Michael Mignone | Caldwell | Jermain Clearville | Irv | ||
| 285 | Eldin Gashi | West Essex | Isaiah Lambert | Irv | ||
| At Large | Christian Bastante | West Essex | Franco Russomanno | Bel | ||
| At Large | Dom Holler | Caldwell | Ethan Pinilis | Mont | ||
| At Large | Antonio Maiden | Nutley | Owen Troesch | Mill | ||
| Honorable Mention | ||||||
| Bloomfield | Ahlexa Montalvo | Dante Palmer | Jahrod Hughes | |||
| Bloomfield | Allysandra Montalvo | Joey Vallone | Nahzire Evans | |||
| Caldwell | Ben Lattimer | Joshua Cabrera | Noah Alequin | |||
| Caldwell | Julian Casale | Daniel Muwanga | Ben Doumbia | |||
| Livingston | Dominic LaPolla | Luke Talbert | Kenji Shimizu | |||
| Livingston | Christopher Taddeo | Tim Chinchilla | Nikhil Chatterjee | |||
| Seton Hall | Will Ligotti | Richie Galiotto | ||||
| Seton Hall | Lucas Campos | Pierce Asfalg | ||||
| West Essex | Chris Nigro | Daniel San Martin | ||||
| West Essex | Doug Taylor | David Celi | ||||
| West Orange | Sean Harrington | Nico Frazier | ||||
| West Orange | Ethan Young | Saayan Kalra | ||||
| Nutley | Jacob Harlow | Jayden Lee | ||||
| Nutley | Jack Finkelstein | Noah Babboni | ||||