| Division: American |
FIRST TEAM:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Sam Goldenring | Newark Academy |
| 2. Zack Potten | Seton Hall Prep |
| 3. Spencer Weiner | Millburn |
| 4. Cliff Lindholm | Montclair |
| 5. Ben Kim | Seton Hall Prep |
| 6. Jack Carrigan | Livingston |
| 7. Creighton Hendrix | Seton Hall Prep |
SECOND TEAM:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Josh Halpert | Millburn |
| 2. Zach Chaikin | Livingston |
| 3. Andrew Coen | Newark Academy |
| 4. Dan Kwiatkowski | Newark Academy |
| 5. Ryan Polizzi | Montclair Kimberly Academy |
| 6. Kevin Hung | Millburn |
| 7. Will Lane | Seton Hall Prep |
HONORABLE MENTION:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Jack Pterovcik | Seton Hall Prep |
| 2. Ben Reich | Millburn |
| 3. Will Reif | West Essex |
| 4. Ryan Mucci | Montclair Kimberly Academy |
| 5. Zack Paersing | Newark Academy |
| 6. Logan Carter | Montclair |
| 7. Jared Appelbaum | Livingston |
| Division: Liberty |
FIRST TEAM:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Mike Purcell | Nutley |
| 2. Frank Ferrari | Verona |
| 3. Dean Cerimido | Glen Ridge |
| 4. Isabel Gonzalez | Bloomfield |
| 5. Anthony Castronova | Nutley |
| 6. Dominick Pomponio | Nutley |
| 7. Connor Bagen | West Orange |
| 8. Jared Westhoven | Belleville |
SECOND TEAM:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Bill Ferrari | Verona |
| 2. Jacob Ruiz | Glen Ridge |
| 3. Mitch Garrison | Verona |
| 4. Eric Shaara | Glen Ridge |
| 5. Joao DePaula | Nutley |
| 6. John Sabadics | Nutley |
| 7. Rachel Ruffino | West Orange |
| 8. Dan Messineo | Verona |
HONORABLE MENTION:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. John Franklin | Caldwell |
| 2. Cameron Mehlman | Glen Ridge |
| 3. Mack Lancaster | Bloomfield |
| 4. Chris Torres | Belleville |
| 5. Tom Hickey | Nutley |
| 6. Tyler Jackson | Verona |
| 7. Raymond Lee Hamlin | West Orange |
| 8. Alexa Filion | Caldwell |