| Sport: Baseball | Year: 2021 |
|
Division: Liberty |
FIRST TEAM:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Nick Bergamotto | Caldwell |
| 2. Owen Ayers | Caldwell |
| 3. Tom Radigan | Verona |
| 4. Noah Stennett | West Orange |
| 5. Gil Prial | Caldwell |
| 6. Jalen Fulton | West Orange |
| 7. Jayson Raines | West Orange |
| 8. Zach Hirshorn | Caldwell |
| 9. Ryan Lill | Caldwell |
| 10. Pierce Coppola | Verona |
| 11. Aidan Healey | West Orange |
| 12. Carl Steffens | Newark Academy |
SECOND TEAM:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Luke Nomura | Columbia |
| 2. Ben Mackey | Verona |
| 3. Dario Bryant | Cedar Grove |
| 4. Matthew Bove | West Orange |
| 5. Alfonso Lombardi | Cedar Grove |
| 6. Aidan Pierre | Columbia |
| 7. Chris Baker | Verona |
| 8. Jacob Messeri | Columbia |
| 9. Michael Scaglione | Caldwell |
| 10. Kyle McCaffery | Verona |
| 11. Owen Murphy | West Orange |
| 12. Ray Zamloot | Caldwell |
HONORABLE MENTION:
| Name (First Last) | School |
| 1. Silas Epstein | Newark Academy |
| 2. Jared Dussman | Columbia |
| 3. Charlie Herley | Columbia |
| 4. Sean Mulligan | Verona |
| 5. Jake Milmoe | Verona |
| 6. Nick McNish | Caldwell |
| 7. Ethan Cavallo | Caldwell |
| 8. Brandon Ramirez | Belleville |
| 9. Matt McCann | Belleville |
| 10. Owen Hagstrom | West Orange |
| 11. Malachi Jones | West Orange |
| 12. George Slattery | Cedar Grove |
| 13. Lucas Droge | Cedar Grove |